15 Best Xbox One Mystery Games of 2023

The Xbox one is renowned amongst several gamers for its user-friendly interface and ability to play games natively at 1080p. Read this guide to know more about the best Xbox mystery games. The Xbox one supports hundreds of games spanning across an array of genres. Therefore, you can assume a new role every single day when you immerse yourself in these games’ lifelike storylines. That being said, have you ever wondered what it is like to be a detective? To know about the rarest Nintendo 64 games and their price, click here.

To use your intellect to solve the most baffling of cases? If that’s so, then you should definitely consider getting some Xbox one mystery games. Each game features its own unique storyline, so you’re bound to stick to these games until you solve the mysteries. So, if you’re a mystery lover and looking to try some Xbox mystery games out, we’ve got you covered! And if you are a motorcycle enthusiast, then don’t forget to check these motor cycling games for Xbox.

Here is our list of the top 15 Xbox one mystery games that will keep you engaged.

See Also: How to download Xbox 360 Emulator 

Sherlock Holmes: Crime & Punishment

Everyone knows of Sherlock Holmes, one of the greatest fictional detectives ever written. So, if you’re a massive fan of Sherlock and love to emulate his methods of deduction, then here is a game for you. This game is one of those Xbox detective games where you must find and interpret the clues to figure out the culprit.

crimes and punishment
crimes and punishment

It is also available as an Xbox 360 mystery game. It has received brilliant reviews from critics and gamers, and the storyline is extremely captivating. This game is split into six murder cases, thefts as well as disappearances. So if you’re into Xbox one detective games and are a diehard Sherlock, definitely consider getting this game.

Buy now on Amazon

See Also: The 10 Free Horror Games On Xbox One Multiplayer

What remains of Edith Finch

This game is centered around a character named Edith Finch. She has to bear the brunt of a mysterious curse, causing each but one family member from each generation to die. Each death takes place in a bizarre yet poetic way.


Your job will be to follow along with Edith as she retells the family history and fate. This is one of those Xbox one mystery games that is bound to get you a bit emotional. All in all, the game has received brilliant reviews and was received well by several gamers too. The game also won a BAFTA Game award and British Academy Games Award for Best Game 2017. So, do check it out if the storyline interests you.

Buy now on Amazon

See also: Games Like Life is Strange | Top 4 Picks

Outer Wilds

This is one of those Xbox one mystery games designed for those who seek to see the bigger picture in life. This game is much more than finding the culprit for a crime. It is a game that seeks to answer the question of what exactly is really out there in the universe.

outer wilds
outer wilds

The whole storyline revolves around an unnamed astronaut who has figured that the world is stuck in a 22-minute time loop. The objective of the game is to solve the clues on the various worlds. Each solved clue will ultimately take you one step closer to your goal, which is to save the universe. Outer Wilds was critically acclaimed and has received several awards too.

Buy now on Amazon

Return of Obra Dinn

The return of Obra Dinn is centered around a lost ship that has made an appearance after five years. Your job is to find out what had happened on the ship.

obra din
obra din

This includes figuring out what has happened to it, the passengers on board, and everyone who had lost their lives on the ship. The graphics, monochromatic art style, and the gameplay is what really tie this game altogether, making it a great gaming experience.

Buy now on Microsoft.

The vanishing of Ethan Carter

The vanishing of Ethan Carter is a strong contender for one of the best Xbox one mystery games to have ever been released. This game combines the best of both horror and mystery.

ethan carter
ethan carter

The story is centered around a 12-year-old boy named Ethan Carter who goes missing. This mysterious disappearance creates a series of tragic events in Red Creek Valley. Solve the clues to uncover the big mystery at the end of the game.

Buy now on Microsoft.

Batman: Arkham Asylum

For all the gamers out there who are a sucker for Batman, this is the game for you. It is an action-adventure game whichh centers around Batman as he battles his long-time arch-nemesis, The Joker.


The game’s primary focus is on Batman’s combat and stealth abilities, detective skills, and gadgets that can be applied in combat and exploration. You can undertake missions and unlock new areas to progress further into the game. It is a sure buy for all the Batman lovers out there. Overall, it has also received great reviews from its players.

Buy now on Amazon

L.A. Noire

L. A Noire is one of the last but certainly not the least Xbox one crime games on our list. This is a game based in the 1940s and consists of baffling mysteries and crimes. Solve each crime to climb the ranks within the L.A.P.D.

la noire
la Noire

The developers of the game came out with a remaster in 2017, making the experience better than ever. L.A. Noire portrays a laser-focused story with not much room for distraction. Each murder is just as gripping as the next. This game is definitely the best in getting you to feel like a true cop that strives to fight crime each day of their life.

Buy now on Amazon

So here is our list of the best Xbox one mystery games. Each game features a unique storyline and plot twists to keep you engaged. 

See Also: Best Xbox One Emulator 

The Wolf Among US

This is a Telltale game series dependent on well-insightful stories, ideal for the mystery kind. The game was delivered in 2013 and is outstanding amongst other mystery fantasy games.

the wolf among us- detective games for xbox one
The Wolf Among Us- detective games for Xbox one

The game comprises five continuous episodes. In this game, you need to presume a remorseless and bleeding murder and keep the fantasy characters and hidden communities mysterious from the rest of the world.

Buy now on Amazon

The Walking Dead

Isn’t the most mysterious and adventurous game feel all the more by its name? “The Walking Dead” is adjusted from the 2012 Telltale 5-scene comic.

the walking dead- xbox mystery games
The Walking Dead- Xbox mystery games

The game has a similar vision as the opening of the zombie apocalypse comic book. All characters, visual depiction, ongoing interaction are in the best condition and more centered around the plot.

Buy now on Amazon

Life Is Strange

This is a 5-episode realistic mystery experience video game that is developing into an honor-dominating series of games where you can encounter otherworldly exciting bends and turns.

life is strange- mystery games for xbox one
Life is Strange- mystery games for Xbox one.

Speaking of the game, every scene expects to make a crucial moment by interfacing your present with the past. The principle undertaking of the game is to tackle world issues like sadness, suicide, harassment, brutality, and significant misfortune, as guaranteed.

Buy now on Amazon

Unmechanical: Extended

This is the best creation game for Xbox One. This is a basic and clear mystery game with 2.5D graphics. All the player needs to do is to settle the mystery of the student project issue by gathering pieces that can keep him occupied in the game for a few hours.

unmechanical- extended
Unmechanical- Extended

Although the game is not much known, critics have given it positive reviews. On the off chance that you allow yourself an opportunity to play, you might be shocked.

Buy now on Amazon

Portal 2

There are numerous mysterious portal games. Portal 2 is a continuation of the Portal series. A greater amount of the best games is Portal’s best game. The game has new difficulties, more hindrances, and better plans to address mysteries in the second series.

portal 2
Portal 2

Speaking of the games, you can play with companions or make your own. The game has the most intelligent machine built into the weapon to shoot you. By playing, you can find out about it.

Buy now on Amazon

Valiant Hearts: The Great Wars

Xbox One might be the first stage to deliver a particularly dark and mysterious game. The game’s plot is a piece interlaced because it attempts to portray love and bliss in one spot for the sake of destiny.

valiant hearts- xbox detective games
Valiant Hearts- Xbox detective games

Valiant Hearts is to take part in close-quarters warfare, and greedy issues in reality. Pack a box of tissues because there is no assurance that you won’t cry after the game.

Buy now on Amazon


This is an incredible first-person anticipation game brimming with mysteries. This game should be played because it has a ton of mental crust in it.

firewatch- xbox one crime solving games
Firewatch- Xbox one crime-solving games

Discussing the game, in this mysterious game, the passionate line of an individual’s life is on the opposite finish of the radio. Yet, you need to discover genuine and exciting recollections between games.

Buy now on Amazon

The Turning Test

Imagine a scenario in which they disclose to you that you control a worldwide space specialist. Will it be entertaining? In this game, you need to control a space specialist working in Jupiter, the Moon, and Europa.

the turning test
The Turning Test

You need to assist them with dealing with the power system since they forgot to open doors and different sorts of machinery.

Buy now on Microsoft

See also: How To Game Share Xbox One To Share Your Library?


If you are someone who loves mystery, then these recommendations will help you choose the best games. These guides on gaming will help gamers to know more. Just like games, there are unique gamers, and you can choose according to your unique style.

Previous article8 Best Xbox 360 Motorcycle Games of 2023
Next article8 Best Xbox 360 Singing Games of 2023
Avatar for Rahul Gupta
He is a Tech Geek, Gadget Expert, SEO Expert, Web Designer, and a Blogger. Having a technology background gives him a unique perspective on what is the latest and best when it comes to tech.